Bellatrix vs Molly: My two cents of pure, unadulterated genius

Ever since Bellatrix Lestrange was killed by Molly Weasley in Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows questions have been asked by fans and people with far too much time on their hands. How was Bellatrix defeated by Molly Weasley? How did a housewife kill Voldemort’s own protagee? Why am I out of Ice Cream? All of these questions have been asked on forums, in chatrooms, Tv Tropes, Mugglenet and Youtube comments. I’ve looked at the situation and, frankly, the answer is pretty obvious.

Bellatrix Lestrange is frequently described as being “a witch of prodigious skill and no conscience”. She’s Voldemort’s most loyal servant, a high-ranking deatheater who has been trained in the Dark arts by Voldemort himself. She kills Sirius and Tonks, as well as being able to deflect one of Dumbledore’s own spells, injures Kingsley Shaklebolt and holds her own against three opponents, Ginny, Hermione and Luna. There is no doubt that she is one of the most magically capable characters in the series. Molly Weasley is the mother of a small army of supporting characters, as well as Ron. She’s a plump little housewife who acts as a motherly figure to orphaned Harry. We see her using magic, she does the housework using magic and is able to send howlers. Molly’s brother’s were Fabian and Gideon Prewett, two powerful aurors who took 5 death eaters to kill them, including Antonin Dolohov, a powerful death eater who then goes onto kill Lupin.

The answer to the question is pretty simple. We know Bellatrix is obsessively loyal to Voldemort, going to extrme lengths to impress him, at one point she proudly declares that she would willingly turn her son over to the Dark Lord (if she had one). We can, therefore, presume that Bellatrix would’ve done her best to kill as many people as possible in the Battle of Hogwarts. She kills her niece, Nymphadora Tonks, an auror who we can presume was a pretty badass witch. The finale of the Battle see’s all the death eaters charging the castle and within a few minutes it is just her and Voldemort left. The death eaters were outnumbered at this point and Bellatrix must have really been tired out by pushing through. Then she starts dueling Hermione, Ginny and Luna, three on one. This is one tired woman, she’s been fighting for more than an hour to prove herself to a man with whom she is obsessed and had to fight an auror and presumably other teachers and members of the Order. Furthermore, she’s not dueling with her own wand. She was disarmed at Malfoy Manor and Hermione used her wand to help them break into Gringotts. Since then, Bellatrix probably would’ve been using a wand taken from another wizard and not one specifically made for her, Ollivander was saved from Death Eater captivity and so there is no longer anymore wands being made for Voldemort’s forces. Wands require witches and wizards to earn their loyalty and to break them in, like a horse, and Bellatrix may not have had time for this and so she is using a wand which is significantly different from her old one, thus affecting her magic.

Most of the problems with the scene come with Molly. So many people have argued that Molly is a weak or, at best, mediocre witch. This is redarded. Molly Wealsey is:

a) A woman who uses magic constantly in her everyday life. She gets good practice from her housework.

b) Related to two powerful aurors, something which may have been inherited.

Molly is also far more energized than Bellatrix. She worked defensive magic, Bellatrix had to attack. It was easier for Molly to defend than it was for Bellatrix to get into the school. Furthermore, towards the end of the battle, the Hogwart’s army outnumbered Voldemort’s and therefore Molly may have had to done less work and fighting than Bellatrix. Furthermore, Bellatrix has killed Tonks and Molly may have known this. From what we see in the books, Molly seems to be really fond of Tonks and so there is an aspect of revenge in the mix. So Bellatrix is dueling Luna, Hermione and Ginny and one of her curses narrowly misses Ginny and Molly utters one of my favourite lines “NOT MY DAUGHTER YOU BITCH!”. So Molly and Bellatrix are dueling and, naturally, Bellatrix is cool and concentrated. She doesn’t underestimate her opponent at all. Oh, wait, not she didn’t. She taunts Molly, talking about what her children will do once she has killed their mother, just like Fred. Yeah, smart move Bella, insult a woman’s dead son. Molly gets pissed.

Casual Sadism: Empowering housewives since 1842

So now we have an exhausted witch with a wand that isn’t her own which she hasn’t broken in yet (pretty much the biggest factor) fighting a woman who practices magic daily whose brothers were powerful aurors fighting a woman who has almost killed her daughter, murdered a witch of whom she was found and is now taunting her about the death of her son. Yeah, I think the answer to the question is obvious. Bellatrix was just completely run down, Molly was always going to win. It’s simple, the odds were stacked against Bellatrix, regardless of the fact that had she had her own wand, she may well have won.


3 thoughts on “Bellatrix vs Molly: My two cents of pure, unadulterated genius

  1. I think it boiled down to, that Molly had love on her side, after all she was the embellishment of maternal love in the HP series . Bella (as I affectionately call her) tried to kill poor Ginny, and in doing so provoked such an almighty maternal instinct in dear molly, that presented its self in such magical skill, that I dout she even knew excited. You should also remember that is was written by JK, and she holds such things her close to her, as seen from book 1 when Lilly died for Harry.

    It’s also worth noting that there was some underhand magic going on. The fact that Harry went to the forest and was prepared to, and in a way did, die, meant that the power of love was cast over all those he died to protect, creating the same effect as Lilly dying for Harry, explaining why no ones who fought against You Know Who died in the second part fo the battle of Hogwarts.


  2. I do think that the whole maternal love point played a large factor. Rowling has gone on record saying that Molly’s caring, sentimental love for her family contrasts perfectl with Bella’s unconditional, obsessive love of Voldemort. It’s a legitimate point that Molly might not have known she could duel so powerfully but, to be honest, it shouldn’t take the reader by suprise. She’s related to two powerful aurors and uses magic every day, she’s had more than enough practice. Plus there’s the point about Harry’s sacrifice. Sorry but didn’t that just apply to Voldemort? I mean, none of his spells hold on anyone, like with Neville. I thought that’s how the sacrifice thing went. Ok so no one died in the last part of the battle but couldn’t that have been coincidence? Or maybe the idea that the death eaters were outnumbered and suffered from low morale because Voldemort failed to kill Harry with a direct killing curse for the umpteenth time…Maybe…I’m still not sure, anywho, yu raise som interesting points, thanks for commenting! 🙂


  3. No Problem! However I stick by my point, I think it would have been JK’s intention that love is what drew Molly to be able to kill Bella. JK has factored in motherly love all through the series, and I believe it would have meant more to her, and symbolised more if it was down to love, rather than genes. But the fact is, only JK knows!
    On the second point however, I’m not sure if it was a coincidence, we will likely never know, and that goes for JK too! JK made clear that no one knows the true power of love, as it is the most powerful and mysterious kind of magic. After all there is a ever-locked room in the Department of Mysteries that is dedicated to investigating it (to quote; “”There is a room in the Department of Mysteries that is kept locked at all times. It contains a force that is at once more wonderful and more terrible than death, than human intelligence, than the forces of nature. It is also, perhaps, the most mysterious of the many subjects for study that reside there. It is the power held within that room that you possess in such quantities and which Voldemort has not at all.”).
    So what we concluded is that we may on speculate on both points, which I find fun!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.